Difference between revisions of "Demonstratives"

From Scottish Gaelic Grammar Wiki
Jump to: navigation, search
Line 4: Line 4:
 
! rowspan=1 |
 
! rowspan=1 |
 
|-
 
|-
|align="left"|'''(i) demonstrative adjectives''' - modify a noun and succeed it in the sentence
+
|align="left"|'''(i) Demonstrative Adjectives''' - modify a noun and succeed it in the sentence
 
|-
 
|-
|align="left"|'''(ii) demonstrative pronouns''' - take the place of a determiner phrase
+
|align="left"|'''(ii) Demonstrative Pronouns''' - take the place of a determiner phrase
 
|-
 
|-
|align="left"|'''(iii) demonstrative adverbs''' - mark a difference between adverbs of location (I am ''here'') versus adverbs of motion (I went ''here'')
+
|align="left"|'''(iii) Demonstrative Adverbs''' - mark a difference between adverbs of location (I am ''here'') versus adverbs of motion (I went ''here'')
 
|}
 
|}
  
  
Scottish Gaelic marks demonstratives in reference to distance from the speaker in three degrees: 'proximant', 'distal', and 'far distal'.  
+
Scottish Gaelic marks demonstratives in reference to distance from the speaker in three degrees:
 +
 
 +
 
 +
 
 +
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align:center; cellpadding="3"
 +
! rowspan=1 |
 +
|-
 +
|align="left"|'''proximant''' - modify a noun and succeed it in the sentence
 +
|-
 +
|align="left"|'''distal''' - take the place of a determiner phrase
 +
|-
 +
|align="left"|'''far distal''' - mark a difference between adverbs of location (I am ''here'') versus adverbs of motion (I went ''here'')
 +
|}
 +
 
 +
 
 +
 
 +
As seen in the table, the three different levels correspond roughly to the English 'here', 'there', and 'yonder'. An interesting feature of these three levels is that they can be used to indicate spatial as well as temporal distance. When the Proximate Distal demonstrative adjective (ud) is used to describe a noun, then typically the noun is something out of sight for both the speaker and the listener. The 2nd degree demonstrative adjective (sin), on the other hand, marks the noun in question as being something far away but within sight.
 +
 
 +
Similarly, the same demonstratives can be used to indicate distance in a more abstract, temporal manner. When the 2nd degree 'sin' is used in reference to come temporal concept ("an latha sin" 'that day') it is meant to indicate that there is some day in the future that is being discussed, and that the day is specific. Whereas if the speaker uses the 3rd degree 'ud' in reference to a day in the future ("an latha ud" 'some day (in the future)') it is meant that the day is hypothetical.  
 +
 
 +
 
  
  
Line 51: Line 71:
 
|-
 
|-
 
|}
 
|}
 
 
As seen in the table, the three different levels correspond roughly to the English 'here', 'there', and 'yonder'. An interesting feature of these three levels is that they can be used to indicate spatial as well as temporal distance. When the Proximate Distal demonstrative adjective (ud) is used to describe a noun, then typically the noun is something out of sight for both the speaker and the listener. The 2nd degree demonstrative adjective (sin), on the other hand, marks the noun in question as being something far away but within sight.
 
 
Similarly, the same demonstratives can be used to indicate distance in a more abstract, temporal manner. When the 2nd degree 'sin' is used in reference to come temporal concept ("an latha sin" 'that day') it is meant to indicate that there is some day in the future that is being discussed, and that the day is specific. Whereas if the speaker uses the 3rd degree 'ud' in reference to a day in the future ("an latha ud" 'some day (in the future)') it is meant that the day is hypothetical.
 
  
  

Revision as of 16:37, 3 September 2012

Demonstratives in Gaelic can take the form:

(i) Demonstrative Adjectives - modify a noun and succeed it in the sentence
(ii) Demonstrative Pronouns - take the place of a determiner phrase
(iii) Demonstrative Adverbs - mark a difference between adverbs of location (I am here) versus adverbs of motion (I went here)


Scottish Gaelic marks demonstratives in reference to distance from the speaker in three degrees:


proximant - modify a noun and succeed it in the sentence
distal - take the place of a determiner phrase
far distal - mark a difference between adverbs of location (I am here) versus adverbs of motion (I went here)


As seen in the table, the three different levels correspond roughly to the English 'here', 'there', and 'yonder'. An interesting feature of these three levels is that they can be used to indicate spatial as well as temporal distance. When the Proximate Distal demonstrative adjective (ud) is used to describe a noun, then typically the noun is something out of sight for both the speaker and the listener. The 2nd degree demonstrative adjective (sin), on the other hand, marks the noun in question as being something far away but within sight.

Similarly, the same demonstratives can be used to indicate distance in a more abstract, temporal manner. When the 2nd degree 'sin' is used in reference to come temporal concept ("an latha sin" 'that day') it is meant to indicate that there is some day in the future that is being discussed, and that the day is specific. Whereas if the speaker uses the 3rd degree 'ud' in reference to a day in the future ("an latha ud" 'some day (in the future)') it is meant that the day is hypothetical.



Gaelic Demonstratives

Pronoun Adj ADVmovement ADVlocation English
Proximate seo seo an-seo an-sheo this
Distal sin sin an-sin an-shin that
Far Distal siud ud an-siud an-shiud yonder


Transitivity

Demonstratives in Gaelic, just like those found in other languages, can be used in two different ways: transitively or intransitively. Intransitive demonstratives are used on their own without any other elements such as in example (1). Transitive demonstratives, on the other hand, are always collocated with a noun as demonstrated in example (2).


1) this is mine

2) this book is mine

Transitive demonstratives in Gaelic are created by combining an article, a noun, and a demonstrative particle, in that order. There are three demonstrative particles: seo proximate (this), sin distal (that), siud or 'ud or siud far distal (yonder).

3)

an seo
the dog this
'this dog'

4)

an sin
the dog that
'that dog'

5)

an 'ud/siud
the dog yonder
'yonder dog'

If the noun is modified by an adjective, the adjective comes before the demonstrative particle:

6)

an mòr seo
the dog big this
'this big dog'


Intransitive demonstratives in Gaelic do not need any other elements such as an article and a noun.

7)

Thoir dhomh seo
give to.me this
'Give me this'

8)

Thoir dhomh sin
give to.me that
'Give me that'

Tense

Distribution

References